After Town Bans Flock, Councilmember Crashes Out, Proposes Internet and Phone Ban

· privacy · Source ↗

TLDR

  • Bandera, Texas (pop. ~900) voted 3-2 to end its Flock Safety LPR contract; a dissenting councilmember then proposed banning all cell phones, GPS devices, and internet services.

Key Takeaways

  • Bandera received a state grant for eight Flock Safety AI license plate reader cameras; vandals repeatedly destroyed the poles, forcing the town to cover replacement costs.
  • The 3-2 council vote immediately terminates the Flock contract after months of resident opposition at public meetings.
  • Councilmember Jeff Flowers, a Flock supporter, responded with the “Bandera Declaration of Digital Independence,” framing total tech prohibition as the logical endpoint of privacy arguments.
  • His proposals include a total ban on outward-facing cameras, cellular and GPS-capable devices within city limits, and all internet services and electronic record-keeping.
  • Flowers cited the 1880 standard: paper ledgers and cash only, positioning this as a reductio ad absurdum against privacy advocates.

Hacker News Comment Review

  • Commenters read Flowers’ proposal as deliberate bad-faith provocation rather than genuine policy, closer to Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” than a sincere legislative agenda.
  • Several commenters flagged that the intensity of Flowers’ personal reaction to the Flock cancellation is itself a signal worth scrutinizing, raising questions about undisclosed financial or political stakes.
  • The broader thread sees an opening: a sincere GDPR-style counter-proposal could call the bluff and reframe the privacy debate on stronger ground.

Notable Comments

  • @fred_is_fred: Notes Texas open records law as a tool to surface whether Flowers has a personal stake in the Flock contract outcome.
  • @VoidWhisperer: Argues Flowers publicly demonstrated he cannot govern with proportionality, damaging any future electoral prospects in the town.

Original | Discuss on HN